Google Nexus One: Iphone Killer or Droid Alternative?

Its Out .. Its Out .. Its Out …

Well, the Google Phone (a.k.a “Nexus 1” meaning there is plenty of scope for 2,3,4 etc.) has been handed to the Google employees and the web is abuzz about the next big thing. There are even some videos out there showing this “futuristic” google device. The longest one from France is embedded at the bottom of this post. For those of you who have not been following the buzz, Nexus One is the phone that Google has designed and outsourced the manufacturing to HTC.  With Nexus One, Google is no more a purely service oriented player. With AMOLED screen, 5Mp camera, 3G for TMobile and the ususals with a pleasing form factor, the Android fans are already salivating 🙂

So is this a great phone or what? But is it going to be an iphone killer? Coming from a self professed iphone fanboy, this may or may not mean a lot but “I don’t think so”. Nexus One definitely seems to have a superior hardware (and so does droid) but its the same old Android OS and the same old school architecture. If you have used the iphone, the differentiator is not the hardware or software in particular, its the user experience. Apple boldly rethought the phone with  iPhone with one thing in mind – the user, not so with the Android OS. Its just Unix/Linux ported to run on your phone with a good UI – Thats a bit harsh but its pretty close to the truth.

In my mind, Nexus One does not bring anything new to the iPhone VS Android battle. Motorola Droid already did that with superior hardware & blitz marketing. And what Nexus One will do is this -“Droid Does and so does Nexus One”. I can only speculate on whether the companies creating phones for the Android OS knew about Nexus One. If not, its kind of back stabbing by Google and if they did, what were these guys thinking? Imagine if Apple had released their open source Mobile OS to the world and after companies had invested huge amount of money (and changed their strategies to switch to that OS), imagine Apple coming out with the iPhone. That’s kind of an impossible analogy (since Apple will never ever release an open source OS cause it might be free :)), but that’s what has happened here and its a pretty bold (and risky) move by Google to do so. It kind of muddles the strategy for Android OS.

Bottom-line, with so many android alternatives out there,  another hardware running the same OS will not be a game changer. But for all you Google fans out there (and that includes me except for few things), knock yourself out !!!

Click Here for a full feature list for Nexus One posted on Engadget


Google Vs Apple: the way I see it

It all started when Google launched Android and it reached a crescendo when Apple refused the Google Voice App. But is it really Google Vs Apple? And who loses from it? Me ? Me being an apple fanboy with an iPhone.

Yes and No. And “No” does not signify that I am in denial 🙂 Hear me out.

Yes I definetly miss out on really cool apps from google (voice, latitude, navigation etc.). But Google misses out too because sadly there are alternatives to that in the ever growing app store. So it Misses out on millions of iPhone users including me. And we are certainly not going to switch to an android phone any soon. So does google care? It should because android will certainly not wipe out iphone in my lifetime. Not even close. So, it cannot ignore such a huge consumer base for long especially since it knows that any of its app would become the No. 1 App on the app store in a heartbeat. Does Apple care? Not really. 100-150k apps trump a few apps from Google any day and dilutes the significance of the issue. However, it should relent just so that it does not disenchant its loyal fans due to all the bad PR that its got because of this.

But does apple care about the android platform? You betcha. And maybe the shutting out of Google Apps is a offshoot of its bigger strategy to outdo Android. Since MS failed to step up and pose any serious challenge to Apple Iphone, Google stepped up and in a big way. Everybody agrees that Android will be challenging the iphone pretty soon. So what happens now? Well this is exactly what an Iphone user wanted – someone to give tough competition to iphone to keep Apple on its toes so that the updates and enhancements keep coming. And this is healthy competition and as per conventional wisdom, when companies compete, consumers win.

It will however be interesting to see who comes on the top. These are 2 companies with very different philosophies and business model – one charges for everything and the other offers everything for free, one believes in tight control over its users and the other believes in total freedom. So as I said, its going to be really interesting.

I will not touch on the brewing OS battle between the companies – Apple is supposedly releasing the apple tablet and companies (like the eviGroup) are already out with an android based wallet and a tablet. But as I said .. That discussion is for another day since my bus is reaching home and this is all I have time for 🙂